AMC 10 Step by Step

2019 AMC 10B Problem 3

P1-10~3 minPrint

In a high school with 500500 students, 40%40\% of the seniors play a musical instrument, while 30%30\% of the non-seniors do not play a musical instrument. In all, 46.8%46.8\% of the students do not play a musical instrument. How many non-seniors play a musical instrument?

Log in to save your progress.
Show solution without answering

Key insight

Two of the facts are about students who do not play. Count the non-players among seniors and non-seniors, and set the total equal to 46.8% of 500.

Solution

Two of the three percentages are really about students who do not play, so count non-players.

1. Total non-players: 46.8%46.8\% of 500500 is 0.468⋅500=2340.468 \cdot 500 = 234.
2. 40%40\% of seniors play, so 60%60\% of seniors do not play.
3. 30%30\% of non-seniors do not play (this is given directly).
4. Let ss be the number of seniors. Then there are 500−s500 - s non-seniors, and the non-players add up to
0.6s+0.3(500−s)=234.0.6s + 0.3(500 - s) = 234.
5. Simplify: 0.6s+150−0.3s=2340.6s + 150 - 0.3s = 234, so 0.3s=840.3s = 84 and s=280s = 280.
6. Non-seniors: 500−280=220500 - 280 = 220.
7. The question asks for non-seniors who play. Since 30%30\% of them do not play, 70%70\% do: 0.7⋅220=1540.7 \cdot 220 = 154.

Check: non-players are 0.6⋅280+0.3⋅220=168+66=2340.6 \cdot 280 + 0.3 \cdot 220 = 168 + 66 = 234. It matches.

The answer is (B) 154\boxed{\textbf{(B)}\ 154}.

Why this works

When a problem gives percentages of different groups, first put them all in the same category ("do not play" here). Then the pieces add up to the total, and one equation finds the group sizes. Be careful at the end: the question asks for players, so one more step turns 30%30\% into 70%70\%. Two wrong choices, 6666 and 220220, are numbers you meet along the way.

Alternative approach

Work backward from the choices. Try (B): if 154154 non-seniors play and that is 70%70\% of them, there are 154÷0.7=220154 \div 0.7 = 220 non-seniors and 280280 seniors. Non-players: 0.3⋅220+0.6⋅280=66+168=2340.3 \cdot 220 + 0.6 \cdot 280 = 66 + 168 = 234, which is 46.8%46.8\% of 500500. It works.

Concise solution

A shorter write-up, the way contest solutions are usually written. It may take a different route from the solution above.

Work entirely with the students who do not play. Let ss be the number of seniors, so there are 500−s500 - s non-seniors.

  • Seniors who do not play: 60%60\% of ss, or 0.6s0.6s.
  • Non-seniors who do not play: 30%30\% of 500−s500 - s, or 0.3(500−s)0.3(500 - s).
  • Total non-players: 46.8%46.8\% of 500500, or 234234.

So
0.6s+0.3(500−s)=234⟹0.3s+150=234⟹s=280.0.6s + 0.3(500 - s) = 234 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad 0.3s + 150 = 234 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad s = 280.
There are 500−280=220500 - 280 = 220 non-seniors, and 70%70\% of them play: 0.7⋅220=1540.7 \cdot 220 = 154.

The answer is (B) 154\boxed{\textbf{(B)}\ 154}.

Review in the AoPS books

Similar problems

Problem © Mathematical Association of America (MAA), American Mathematics Competitions. Reproduced for non-commercial educational use. Solution and commentary are original to this site.