AMC 10 Step by Step

2021 AMC Fall 10B Problem 25

P21-25~15 minPrint

A rectangle with side lengths 11{ } and 3,3, a square with side length 1,1, and a rectangle RR are inscribed inside a larger square as shown. The sum of all possible values for the area of RR can be written in the form mn\tfrac mn , where mm and nn are relatively prime positive integers. What is m+n?m+n?

figure

Log in to save your progress.
Show solution without answering

Key insight

The 1 by 3 rectangle and unit square fix the big square. In units where it is 10 by 10, rectangle R gives a quadratic with two answers.

Solution

Step 1: pin down the tilt. The 1×31 \times 3 rectangle is tilted. Say its short side (length 11) goes pp across and rr up, so p2+r2=1p^2 + r^2 = 1. The long side is at a right angle to it, so it goes 3r3r across and 3p3p up.

  1. Width of the big square. The 1×31 \times 3 rectangle touches the left, bottom and right sides. Across the bottom it spans one long side plus one short side: width =3r+p= 3r + p.
  2. Height of the big square. Go up the left side: the long side rises 3p3p to reach the left wall, then the short side rises rr to the rectangle's top corner. The unit square sits on that corner: its side to the left wall has length 11 and runs pp across (from the corner back to the wall), so, just like the rectangle's short side, it rises rr; and its next side rises pp to reach the top. Height =3p+r+r+p=4p+2r= 3p + r + r + p = 4p + 2r.
  3. Square, so width = height. 3r+p=4p+2r3r + p = 4p + 2r, which gives r=3pr = 3p. Then p2+9p2=1p^2 + 9p^2 = 1, so p=110p = \frac{1}{\sqrt{10}} and r=310r = \frac{3}{\sqrt{10}}. The big square's side is 3r+p=1010=103r + p = \frac{10}{\sqrt{10}} = \sqrt{10}.

Step 2: nicer units. Measure lengths in units of 110\frac{1}{\sqrt{10}}. Then p=1p = 1, r=3r = 3, and the big square is 10×1010 \times 10 with corner (0,0)(0, 0). Areas in these units are 1010 times too big, so divide by 1010 at the end. The pieces now have whole-number corners:
- 1×31 \times 3 rectangle: (9,0)(9, 0), (10,3)(10, 3), (1,6)(1, 6), (0,3)(0, 3). Its top side runs from (1,6)(1, 6) to (10,3)(10, 3) along the line x+3y=19x + 3y = 19.
- Unit square: (1,6)(1, 6), (0,9)(0, 9), (3,10)(3, 10), (4,7)(4, 7). Rectangle RR has its corner at P=(4,7)P = (4, 7).

Step 3: rectangle RR. RR has corner P=(4,7)P = (4, 7), one corner UU on the top side y=10y = 10, one on the right side x=10x = 10, and one corner QQ on the line x+3y=19x + 3y = 19.

1. Going from PP to UU climbs 33 (from 77 to 1010). Call the sideways distance kk, so P→UP \to U is "kk across, 33 up."
2. Side PQPQ is at a right angle to PUPU, so it goes in the direction "33 across, kk down." Say PQPQ is λ\lambda times that: Q=(4+3λ, 7−kλ)Q = (4 + 3\lambda,\ 7 - k\lambda).
3. Fourth corner on the right side. The fourth corner is UU moved the same way as P→QP \to Q, so its xx-coordinate is 4+k+3λ=104 + k + 3\lambda = 10. So k+3λ=6k + 3\lambda = 6.
4. QQ on the line. (4+3λ)+3(7−kλ)=19(4 + 3\lambda) + 3(7 - k\lambda) = 19, which simplifies to λ(k−1)=2\lambda(k - 1) = 2.
5. Solve. Put k=6−3λk = 6 - 3\lambda into step 4: λ(5−3λ)=2\lambda(5 - 3\lambda) = 2, so 3λ2−5λ+2=03\lambda^2 - 5\lambda + 2 = 0, which factors as (3λ−2)(λ−1)=0(3\lambda - 2)(\lambda - 1) = 0.
- λ=1\lambda = 1, k=3k = 3: PUPU is (3,3)(3, 3), length 323\sqrt2, and PQPQ is (3,−3)(3, -3), length 323\sqrt2. Area 1818.
- λ=23\lambda = \frac23, k=4k = 4: PUPU is (4,3)(4, 3), length 55, and PQPQ is (2,−83)(2, -\frac83), length 4+649=103\sqrt{4 + \frac{64}{9}} = \frac{10}{3}. Area 503\frac{50}{3}.
6. Both fit. For λ=1\lambda = 1 the corners are (4,7),(7,10),(10,7),(7,4)(4,7), (7,10), (10,7), (7,4). For λ=23\lambda = \frac23 they are (4,7),(8,10),(10,223),(6,133)(4,7), (8,10), (10, \frac{22}{3}), (6, \frac{13}{3}). In both, QQ lands on the rectangle's top side between x=1x = 1 and x=10x = 10.

Step 4: real areas. Divide by 1010: 1810=95\frac{18}{10} = \frac95 and 503÷10=53\frac{50}{3} \div 10 = \frac53. The sum is
95+53=2715+2515=5215,\frac95 + \frac53 = \frac{27}{15} + \frac{25}{15} = \frac{52}{15},
so m+n=52+15=67m + n = 52 + 15 = 67.

The answer is (E) 67\boxed{\textbf{(E)}\ 67}.

Why this works

Two of the three pieces are rigid enough to fix the big square completely, while RR has some freedom, which is why the problem says "all possible values." Three touching conditions on RR give equations with a quadratic at the end, so two rectangles work. Choosing units that put every known corner at whole-number coordinates keeps the algebra small.

Concise solution

A shorter write-up, the way contest solutions are usually written. It may take a different route from the solution above.

Step 1: the fixed pieces. Let the 1×31 \times 3 rectangle's long side make angle θ\theta with the horizontal, its corners on the left, bottom and right sides of the big square. Its horizontal span is the big side, s=3cos⁡θ+sin⁡θs = 3\cos\theta + \sin\theta; its top corner TT has height 3sin⁡θ+cos⁡θ3\sin\theta + \cos\theta and is sin⁡θ\sin\theta from the left side.

The unit square has a vertex at TT, one on the left side and one on the top. Its side from TT to the left side has run sin⁡θ\sin\theta, hence rise cos⁡θ\cos\theta; the next side rises sin⁡θ\sin\theta more to reach the top, so s=4sin⁡θ+2cos⁡θs = 4\sin\theta + 2\cos\theta. Equating: tan⁡θ=13\tan\theta = \frac13 and s=10s = \sqrt{10}.

Step 2: coordinates. Scale by 10\sqrt{10} so the big square is [0,10]2[0,10]^2. The rectangle's top side is the segment of x+3y=19x + 3y = 19 from (1,6)(1,6) to (10,3)(10,3), and the unit square's free vertex is P=(4,7)P = (4,7).

Step 3: rectangle RR. RR has vertex PP, vertex QQ on x+3y=19x + 3y = 19, a vertex on x=10x = 10, and vertex UU on y=10y = 10. Let its sides from PP be u(cos⁡α,sin⁡α)u(\cos\alpha, \sin\alpha) toward UU and q(sin⁡α,−cos⁡α)q(\sin\alpha, -\cos\alpha) toward QQ. The conditions are usin⁡α=3u\sin\alpha = 3, q(3cos⁡α−sin⁡α)=6q(3\cos\alpha - \sin\alpha) = 6, and qsin⁡α+ucos⁡α=6q\sin\alpha + u\cos\alpha = 6. With t=tan⁡αt = \tan\alpha they combine to
6t3−t+3t=6⟹4t2−7t+3=0,\frac{6t}{3 - t} + \frac{3}{t} = 6 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad 4t^2 - 7t + 3 = 0,
so t=34t = \frac34 or t=1t = 1.

For t=34t = \frac34: u=5u = 5, q=103q = \frac{10}{3}, area 503\frac{50}{3}. For t=1t = 1: u=q=32u = q = 3\sqrt2, area 1818. Both fit in the square. Areas scale by 1010, so the true areas sum to 53+95=5215\frac53 + \frac95 = \frac{52}{15}, giving m+n=67m + n = 67.

The answer is (E) 67\boxed{\textbf{(E)}\ 67}.

Review in the AoPS books

Similar problems

Problem © Mathematical Association of America (MAA), American Mathematics Competitions. Reproduced for non-commercial educational use. Solution and commentary are original to this site.