AMC 10 Step by Step

2008 AMC 10B Problem 18

P16-20~3 minPrint

Bricklayer Brenda would take nine hours to build a chimney alone, and Bricklayer Brandon would take 1010 hours to build it alone. When they work together, they talk a lot, and their combined output decreases by 1010 bricks per hour. Working together, they build the chimney in 55 hours. How many bricks are in the chimney?

Log in to save your progress.
Show solution without answering

Key insight

Measure speed in bricks per hour. Brenda lays one ninth of the chimney each hour and Brandon one tenth; together, minus 10 bricks, they must lay one fifth.

Solution

The slowdown is given in bricks per hour, so measure everyone's speed in bricks per hour too. Call the number of bricks in the chimney NN.

1. Brenda builds the whole chimney in 99 hours, so she lays N9\tfrac{N}{9} bricks each hour.
2. Brandon builds it in 1010 hours, so he lays N10\tfrac{N}{10} bricks each hour.
3. Together they would lay N9+N10\tfrac{N}{9} + \tfrac{N}{10} each hour, but talking costs 1010 bricks per hour. Their real speed is N9+N10−10\tfrac{N}{9} + \tfrac{N}{10} - 10.
4. They finish in 55 hours, so their real speed is also N5\tfrac{N}{5} bricks per hour:
N9+N10−10=N5.\frac{N}{9} + \frac{N}{10} - 10 = \frac{N}{5}.
5. Clear the fractions by multiplying every term by 9090:
10N+9N−900=18N.10N + 9N - 900 = 18N.
6. Subtract 18N18N from both sides: N−900=0N - 900 = 0, so N=900N = 900.
7. Check: Brenda lays 100100 per hour, Brandon 9090, together 190−10=180190 - 10 = 180 per hour, and 5×180=9005 \times 180 = 900.

The answer is (B) 900\boxed{\textbf{(B)}\ 900}.

Why this works

Work problems turn into simple equations once everything is written as a speed ("how much per hour"). Speeds of people working together add. Because the slowdown is counted in bricks per hour, the speeds must also be in bricks per hour, which is why the unknown number of bricks shows up in every speed.

Alternative approach

Test the choices, starting with (B). With 900900 bricks, Brenda lays 900÷9=100900 \div 9 = 100 per hour and Brandon 900÷10=90900 \div 10 = 90. Together that is 190−10=180190 - 10 = 180 per hour, and 900÷180=5900 \div 180 = 5 hours. It fits. (With 10001000 bricks, for example, the speeds are 11119111\tfrac19 and 100100, together 20119201\tfrac19 per hour, and 10001000 bricks take less than 55 hours.)

Concise solution

A shorter write-up, the way contest solutions are usually written. It may take a different route from the solution above.

Let the chimney contain NN bricks. Brenda lays N9\tfrac{N}{9} bricks per hour and Brandon lays N10\tfrac{N}{10} bricks per hour. Together, after the 1010-brick-per-hour loss, their rate is N9+N10−10\tfrac{N}{9} + \tfrac{N}{10} - 10. Finishing in 55 hours means this rate equals N5\tfrac{N}{5}:
N9+N10−10=N5.\frac{N}{9} + \frac{N}{10} - 10 = \frac{N}{5}.
Multiply through by 9090:
10N+9N−900=18N⟹N=900.10N + 9N - 900 = 18N \quad\Longrightarrow\quad N = 900.
Check: 100+90−10=180100 + 90 - 10 = 180 bricks per hour, and 5⋅180=9005 \cdot 180 = 900.

The answer is (B) 900\boxed{\textbf{(B)}\ 900}.

Review in the AoPS books

Similar problems

Problem © Mathematical Association of America (MAA), American Mathematics Competitions. Reproduced for non-commercial educational use. Solution and commentary are original to this site.