The altitude to the hypotenuse of a right triangle is divided into two segments of lengths by the median to the shortest side of the triangle. What is the ratio ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
A
Key insight
Put the right angle at the origin. The crossing point and the altitude's foot lie on one line from there; compare how far across each is.
Solution
Only a ratio is asked, so pick an easy size. The letters and are already used by the problem, so write points as : is how far across, is how far up.
- Place the triangle. Put the right angle at , with and . The legs are and and the hypotenuse is , so this is a -- triangle. The shortest side is , the one of length .
2. The altitude from . The hypotenuse drops while moving across, so its steepness (slope) is , and its line is . The altitude is perpendicular to it, so its slope is and, starting at , its line is . Where they meet:
So the foot of the altitude is , with .
- The median to the shortest side. It goes from to the midpoint of , which is . That line is .
4. Where the median crosses the altitude. Set the two heights equal:
Call this point .
5. Compare lengths along the altitude. , and are all on the same straight line from . Along a straight line from , the distance from grows in step with how far across you go. So
The altitude is split into , which is of it, and , which is of it.
6. Pick the smaller piece. is the smaller piece, so , and is the whole altitude . Therefore
The answer is .
Why this works
When a triangle's shape is completely fixed, coordinates turn "where do these two segments cross?" into solving two line equations. The last shortcut saves real work: two points on the same line through the origin can be compared by one coordinate, with no distance formula and no square roots. Choosing side lengths that keep the numbers whole also helps.
Alternative approach
Use balancing weights (mass points). In a right triangle, the altitude splits the hypotenuse so that . Put weight at and at so that balances , and weight at so that balances . Then carries , and balances (weight ) against (weight ), so . The smaller piece is parts out of .
The trap
Reporting the piece next to the right angle, which is the longer one (4/7 of the altitude), instead of the shorter piece x.
Concise solution
The answer is a ratio, so fix a convenient size. Using for coordinates, put the right angle at with
Then , and , so and . The shortest side is the one opposite the angle, namely .
The altitude. The hypotenuse lies on . The altitude from is perpendicular to it, so it runs along the direction , that is, along the line . Substituting into the hypotenuse gives , so and the foot is
The median. The median to joins to the midpoint , so it lies on .
The intersection. Solving gives , so and
Both and lie on the ray from through , so lengths measured from are proportional to first coordinates:
Therefore cuts the altitude in the ratio . The smaller piece is while the whole altitude is , so
The answer is .
Review in the AoPS books
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 7: Special Parts of a Triangle
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 17: Analytic Geometry
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 4: Perimeter and Area (§4.2)
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 6: Right Triangles (§6.5)
Techniques
Place the figure on coordinates and compute · Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed