What is the least positive integer such that is a perfect square?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
Pair (2k-1)! with (2k)! = (2k-1)! times 2k: the product is a square times 2 * 4 * ... * 16 = 2^8 * 8!, whose non-square part is 70.
Solution
Since , the product equals . Group the factorials in consecutive pairs and use :
Doing this for ,
The factor is a square, so everything hinges on . The primes with odd exponent are , and , so the smallest that makes the whole product a square is
The answer is .
Why this works
A product is a perfect square exactly when every prime exponent is even, and the least "fixer" is the product of the primes with odd exponent. Rather than tallying exponents of every prime across sixteen factorials, the pairing trick strips out a huge visible square and leaves a single small number to factor.
Alternative approach
Count exponents directly for each prime: the exponent of in is . For and the terms are for (six terms) and (four terms), both even, which already rules out choices (B), (D), (E).
The trap
Guessing that the large primes 11 and 13 must appear in m; 11 divides six of the factorials and 13 divides four, so their exponents are already even.
Common mistakes
- Guessing that the large primes 11 and 13 must appear in m; 11 divides six of the factorials and 13 divides four, so their exponents are already even.
- Treating carelessly and dropping the factor (the exponent of in is , odd), which would give .
Techniques
Apply an identity: SFFT, sum of squares, difference of cubes, Vieta · Use an invariant, parity, or coloring argument