Ray's car averages 40 miles per gallon of gasoline, and Tom's car averages 10 miles per gallon of gasoline. Ray and Tom each drive the same number of miles. What is the cars' combined rate of miles per gallon of gasoline?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
Combined mileage is total miles over total gallons; with equal distances, choose a convenient distance like 40 miles and count gallons.
Solution
The combined rate is the total distance divided by the total gasoline used. Since the distance is the same for both, pick a convenient one: suppose each drives miles.
Ray uses gallon. Tom uses gallons.
Together they cover miles on gallons, so the combined rate is
The answer is .
Why this works
Miles per gallon is a ratio, and ratios combine by adding numerators and denominators separately, not by averaging. For equal distances , the combined rate is , the harmonic mean of and ; the cancels, which is why any convenient distance works.
Alternative approach
Keep general: total gas , so the rate is .
The trap
Averaging 40 and 10 to get 25; the cars burn different amounts of gas for the same distance, so the poorer car dominates.
Common mistakes
- Averaging 40 and 10 to get 25; the cars burn different amounts of gas for the same distance, so the poorer car dominates.
- Dividing total gallons by total miles, or computing the combined rate for equal gallons (which would give ).
Techniques
Test small/specific values or special cases to find or verify the answer