Rachel and Robert run on a circular track. Rachel runs counterclockwise and completes a lap every 90 seconds, and Robert runs clockwise and completes a lap every 80 seconds. Both start from the same line at the same time. At some random time between 10 minutes and 11 minutes after they begin to run, a photographer standing inside the track takes a picture that shows one-fourth of the track, centered on the starting line. What is the probability that both Rachel and Robert are in the picture?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
Each runner is visible in a time window centered on passing the start: Rachel 618.75 to 641.25 s, Robert 630 to 650 s; overlap 11.25 of 60.
Solution
The photo covers one-fourth of the track centered on the start, that is, one-eighth of a lap on each side of the start line. A runner is in the picture exactly when they are within one-eighth of a lap of the start line, which is within one-eighth of their lap time (in seconds) of a moment when they pass the line. Direction of travel does not matter.
Work in seconds; the picture is taken at a uniformly random time in .
Rachel passes the start every seconds, in particular at (seven laps). One-eighth of is , so she is in the picture for . Her other passings (, ) have windows outside .
Robert passes the start every seconds, in particular at (eight laps). One-eighth of is , so he is in the picture for . His neighboring windows (, ) are outside the minute.
Both are in the picture on the overlap , of length seconds. The probability is
The answer is .
Why this works
A uniformly random time turns the question into lengths of intervals: find each runner's "visible" window, intersect, and divide by the total. Converting a fraction of the track into a fraction of the lap time is the key translation, and centering the windows on the nearest passing of the start line keeps the arithmetic small.
The trap
Using a quarter lap on each side of the start line instead of one-eighth, which doubles each window.
Common mistakes
- Using a quarter lap on each side of the start line instead of one-eighth, which doubles each window.
- Assuming the two events are independent and multiplying the individual probabilities ; the windows are fixed in time, so intersect them instead.
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed