For how many positive integers does there exist at least one positive integer n such that ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
E
Key insight
Taking n = 1 turns the inequality into m <= m + 1, which is true for every positive integer m.
Solution
The question only asks whether some positive integer works for a given , so try the simplest candidate, . The inequality becomes
which holds for every positive integer .
Thus every one of the infinitely many positive integers has a partner .
The answer is .
Why this works
"There exists at least one " is an existence statement, and a single witness settles it. Before doing algebra on an inequality with two unknowns, test the extreme easy values (, ); if one of them works uniformly, the problem is over. For comparison, rewriting as shows that beyond only a few pairs work, which is what makes the finite answer choices tempting.
Alternative approach
Rearrange: , so . With the left side is for all ; with it forces ; with it forces or , . Every is covered by the case alone.
The trap
Assuming n must be large or trying to solve the inequality in general instead of noticing that n = 1 always works.
Common mistakes
- Assuming n must be large or trying to solve the inequality in general instead of noticing that n = 1 always works.
- Counting the pairs with beyond the line and reporting a small finite number.
Techniques
Test small/specific values or special cases to find or verify the answer