Frances stands meters directly south of a locked gate in a fence that runs east-west. Immediately behind the fence is a box of chocolates, located meters east of the locked gate. An unlocked gate lies meters east of the box, and another unlocked gate lies meters west of the locked gate. Frances can reach the box by walking toward an unlocked gate, passing through it, and walking toward the box. It happens that the total distance Frances would travel is the same via either unlocked gate. What is the value of ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
Put the locked gate at the origin: the western route is 17 + (x + 8) by the 8-15-17 triple, and the eastern route is sqrt(15^2 + (x+9)^2) + 9.
Solution
Set the fence along the -axis with the locked gate at the origin, east positive. Then
- Frances is at ,
- the box is at ,
- the eastern unlocked gate is at ,
- the western unlocked gate is at .
Each route is a straight walk to a gate followed by a straight walk along the fence to the box.
Western route. From to is (the -- triple), and from there to the box is . Total: .
Eastern route. From to is , and from there back to the box is . Total: .
Equating and isolating the radical,
Both sides are positive, so square:
The answer is .
Why this works
Coordinates convert a wordy layout into two distances, and the only geometry needed is the Pythagorean theorem applied twice. The terms cancel when the equation is squared, so what looks like a quadratic is really linear. Spotting -- on the western side saves a surd and keeps the algebra on one side of the equation. The general lesson is to draw the axis along the fence and measure everything from one fixed landmark, here the locked gate, so that every position is a single expression in .
The trap
Comparing only the diagonal walks to the two gates and omitting the walks along the fence, 9 metres in the east and x + 8 metres in the west.
Common mistakes
- Comparing only the diagonal walks to the two gates and omitting the walks along the fence, 9 metres in the east and x + 8 metres in the west.
- Reading the description as "the box is metres east of the unlocked gate", which puts that gate at and yields .
- Squaring without first isolating the radical, which produces stray cross terms.
Techniques
Place the figure on coordinates and compute · Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed