Let . For how many real numbers does the graph of pass through the point ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
Sliding the graph sideways does not change its heights. So count how many times the original graph reaches height 25; each such spot gives one value of a.
Solution
1. Turn the condition into an equation. The graph of passes through when putting gives , that is, when
- Count heights instead of shifts. Write . Each value of matches exactly one value of (namely ), and the other way around. So the question becomes: how many numbers make ? In picture form: how many times does the graph of reach height ?
3. Factor to understand its shape. Pull out :
So the graph crosses zero at , and .
- Make a small table of values. Use the zeros plus a few easy points in between:
For example, .
5. Find where the graph passes height .
- From to it goes from up to , so it passes once.
- From to it goes from down to , so it passes again.
- From to it goes from up to , so it passes a third time.
- Show there are no more. The equation is a cubic equation, and a cubic equation has at most real solutions. We found , so that is all of them.
Each of the three values of gives one value of , so there are exactly values of .
The answer is .
Why this works
Shifting a graph left or right moves its points sideways but keeps every height. So "which shifts pass through a point at height " is the same question as "where does the original graph reach height ". To count those spots you do not need to solve the cubic: a table of values shows where the graph goes above and below , and the degree tells you the most solutions there can be.
Alternative approach
Write the equation directly in . Expanding gives , so the condition is
Let and test a few values: , , , . The sign flips three times, so there is a solution between and , one between and , and one between and . A cubic has at most three, so the count is .
The trap
Thinking a cubic reaches each height only once and answering 1, choice (A). Between 0 and 1 the graph rises to a hump of 37.5, so it crosses 25 three times.
Concise solution
First factor:
so has roots , and .
The graph of passes through precisely when . Put . As ranges over the reals so does , and different give different , so the number of valid equals the number of real solutions of . In other words, the question is how many times the fixed cubic reaches the height .
Since means , set
Evaluate at four convenient points:
The sign changes three times, so has a root in each of , and . A cubic has at most three real roots, so there are exactly three, and therefore exactly three values of .
The answer is .
Review in the AoPS books
- Introduction to Algebra, Chapter 16: Functions
- Intermediate Algebra, Chapter 6: Polynomial Division (§6.2, §6.4)
- Intermediate Algebra, Chapter 20: Some Advanced Strategies (§20.2)
- Introduction to Algebra, Chapter 17: Graphing Functions (§17.2)
Techniques
Bound the quantity above/below or estimate to pin it down · Substitute to simplify (u = x+1/x, shifting, scaling)