A silo (right circular cylinder) with diameter 20 meters stands in a field. MacDonald is located 20 meters west and 15 meters south of the center of the silo. McGregor is located 20 meters east and meters south of the center of the silo. The line of sight between MacDonald and McGregor is tangent to the silo. The value of can be written as , where and are positive integers, is not divisible by the square of any prime, and is relatively prime to the greatest common divisor of and . What is the value of ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
A
Key insight
Put the silo's centre at the origin: the line of sight is tangent exactly when its distance from the origin equals 10, one equation in g.
Solution
Place the centre of the silo at the origin, with east the positive -direction and north the positive -direction. The diameter is , so the silo is the circle . The two farmers are at
The line has slope , so its equation is , that is
Tangency to the silo means the distance from the origin to this line equals the radius :
(the numerator is positive because ). Dividing by and squaring,
By the quadratic formula,
Since and only the sign gives ,
The normalisation in the problem picks out this last form: with , , , we have and , as required, while the unreduced fails because . Hence
The answer is .
Why this works
"Tangent to a circle" is one of the few geometric conditions that translates into a single scalar equation, namely distance from centre to line equals radius. Once the centre is at the origin the distance formula is as short as it can be, and the only unknown in it is the coordinate being asked for. This beats chasing the tangent point, which would introduce a second unknown and require an extra perpendicularity condition. The awkward-looking coprimality clause exists only to make the intended form unique, so it is worth reading it as an instruction to reduce the fraction as far as possible before adding.
Alternative approach
Use tangent lengths. The tangent point lies between and on the line of sight, so . From the tangent length from MacDonald is , and from the tangent length from McGregor is . With this gives
which after squaring twice reduces to the same quadratic . It is more work, but it is the route to take if the distance-to-a-line formula is not to hand.
The trap
Using 20 as the radius because the problem says diameter 20, which replaces 10 by 20 in the distance equation and produces g = 80/3, a value that cannot be written in the required form.
Common mistakes
- Using 20 as the radius because the problem says diameter 20, which replaces 10 by 20 in the distance equation and produces g = 80/3, a value that cannot be written in the required form.
- Writing and summing ; the condition on is exactly what rules this form out.
- Leaving as , which violates the requirement that be squarefree.
Techniques
Place the figure on coordinates and compute · Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed