In the following expression, Melanie changed some of the plus signs to minus signs: When the new expression was evaluated, it was negative. What is the least number of plus signs that Melanie could have changed to minus signs?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
The full sum is 2500. Flipping a plus to a minus takes away twice that number, so the flipped numbers must add up to more than 1250.
Solution
1. First find the total with all plus signs. Sums of odd numbers starting at make perfect squares: , , . There are odd numbers from to , so the total is .
2. See what one sign change does. If becomes , the total loses (it is no longer added) and loses another (it is now subtracted). So the total drops by .
3. So if the numbers Melanie flips add up to , the new total is . This is negative exactly when , that is, when .
4. To pass with as few numbers as possible, flip the biggest ones:
5. Add up the biggest, down to . They pair up as , , and so on, giving pairs:
This is less than , so flips are not enough.
6. Add the next one, : , which is more than . So flips work.
Since even the biggest numbers fall short, no set of or fewer can work, and is the least.
The answer is .
Why this works
Changing a plus to a minus takes away twice that number, so "make the total negative" becomes "the flipped numbers must add up to more than half the total." To use as few flips as possible, always take the biggest numbers first. If the biggest cannot reach the target, no other can either.
The trap
Thinking the flipped numbers must add up to more than 2500. Each flipped number also leaves the plus side, so more than half, 1250, is already enough.
Concise solution
There are odd numbers from to , and their sum is .
Changing the sign of a term lowers the total by . If the flipped terms have sum , the new value is , which is negative exactly when .
To reach with as few terms as possible, flip the largest terms. The largest odd numbers are , an arithmetic series with average , so their sum is .
- : , not enough.
- : , works.
The answer is .
Review in the AoPS books
- Introduction to Algebra, Chapter 21: Sequences & Series (§21.1, §21.2, §21.3, §21.4)
- Introduction to Algebra, Chapter 20: Special Functions (§20.2, §20.5)
- Intermediate Algebra, Chapter 17: More Sequences and Series (§17.1, §17.2)
- Introduction to Algebra, Chapter 15: More Inequalities (§15.1, §15.3, §15.4)
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed · Consider the largest/smallest element or boundary case