In the following table, each question mark is to be replaced by "Possible" or "Not Possible" to indicate whether a nonvertical line with the given slope can contain the given number of lattice points (points both of whose coordinates are integers). How many of the 12 entries will be "Possible"?

- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
Two lattice points force a rational slope, and one lattice point plus a rational slope forces infinitely many; so each row allows exactly two of the four counts.
Solution
The rows are slope , nonzero rational slope, irrational slope; the columns are , exactly , exactly , more than lattice points.
Two general facts do most of the work.
- If a line contains two lattice points and , its slope is rational (or the line is vertical). So an irrational-slope line has at most one lattice point.
- If a line with rational slope (lowest terms) contains a lattice point , it also contains , , and so on. So a rational-slope line with one lattice point has infinitely many.
Slope : . If is not an integer, there are lattice points; if is an integer, infinitely many. Exactly or is impossible by fact 2. Possible: and more than .
Nonzero rational slope: has no lattice points (the right side is never an integer for integer : has odd numerator); has infinitely many. Exactly or is impossible by fact 2. Possible: and more than .
Irrational slope: passes through exactly one lattice point, the origin; passes through none. Two or more is impossible by fact 1. Possible: and exactly .
Each row has possible entries, for in all.
The answer is .
Why this works
Lattice points on a line are controlled by the slope's rationality: rational slopes make lattice points periodic (none or infinitely many), irrational slopes cap them at one. Filling a possibility table means proving each "Not Possible" with a general argument and each "Possible" with one concrete example; keep both tools ready.
The trap
Believing a nonzero rational slope line can pass through exactly one or two lattice points; once it hits one, stepping by the reduced (q, p) gives infinitely many.
Common mistakes
- Believing a nonzero rational slope line can pass through exactly one or two lattice points; once it hits one, stepping by the reduced (q, p) gives infinitely many.
- Marking "exactly one" as impossible for irrational slope, forgetting that a lattice point on the line is allowed, just not two.
Techniques
Split into exhaustive cases and handle each · Test small/specific values or special cases to find or verify the answer