Suzanne went to the bank and withdrew . The teller gave her this amount using bills, bills, and bills, with at least one of each denomination. How many different collections of bills could Suzanne have received?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
Everything except the fifty-dollar bills comes in multiples of 20 or 100, so the fifties must come in pairs. Then list the choices by the number of hundreds.
Solution
Organize the count by the number of bills, and for each case find how many ways the rest can be paid.
1. The fifties come in pairs. Twenties and hundreds always add up to a multiple of , and is a multiple of too. So the fifties must also add up to a multiple of . One fifty is , two are , three are , four are : only an even number of fifties works. So the number of fifties is (at least , since there is at least one).
2. One hundred-dollar bill. That leaves for twenties and fifties. Try each even number of fifties:
- fifties , leaving twenties.
- fifties , leaving twenties.
- fifties leave : twenties.
- fifties leaves no twenties, which is not allowed.
So there are ways.
3. Each extra hundred removes one way. Two hundreds leave : fifties can be (with fifties the twenties run out), which is ways. In general, less means one fewer pair of fifties fits.
| hundreds | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| money left | |||||||
| ways |
With hundreds, is left: fifties and twenties is the only way. With hundreds, is left, and fifties would use it all with no twenties, so there is no way.
4. Add up. .
The answer is .
Why this works
Looking at what each bill adds up to shows that the fifties must come in pairs, which cuts the choices in half. After that, fixing one kind of bill at a time turns the problem into short lists you can count. Build the "at least one of each" rule into every case from the start, so you do not have to remove extra cases at the end.
Alternative approach
Use letters. Let , , be the numbers of , , bills, each at least . Dividing by gives .
- , and are even, so is even, so is even. Write with .
- Then , so .
- must be at least , so is at most . Also and are at least , so is at least .
- If , there are choices for , and is then fixed. Adding over : .
The trap
Forgetting 'at least one of each kind of bill', so that zero twenties or zero hundreds get counted too.
Concise solution
Let be the numbers of , and bills. Then , or after dividing by ,
Every term except is even, so is even: write with . Dividing by ,
Since , we need ; since , we need . Each pair with determines , and there are such pairs. Summing over :
The answer is .
Review in the AoPS books
- Introduction to Number Theory, Chapter 7: Algebra With Integers
- Introduction to Counting & Probability, Chapter 1: Counting Is Arithmetic
- Intermediate Algebra, Chapter 20: Some Advanced Strategies (§20.2)
- Prealgebra, Chapter 15: Problem-Solving Strategies (§15.2)
Techniques
Organized listing / direct enumeration · Substitute to simplify (u = x+1/x, shifting, scaling)