Let be the set of circles in the coordinate plane that are tangent to each of the three circles with equations , , and . What is the sum of the areas of all circles in ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
E
Key insight
Tangency to both concentric circles forces radius 3 (center at distance 5) or radius 5 (center at distance 3); each case meets the third circle's tangency condition at four centers.
Solution
Let be the origin; the first two circles have radii and . A circle of radius with center at distance from tangent to both must lie inside the big circle (a circle outside it cannot reach the small one), so . It is tangent to the small circle either externally, , or by enclosing it, .
- Externally: , so and .
- Enclosing: , so and .
Now impose tangency to the third circle, center , radius : the distance from our center to must be or .
Case . The center lies on the circle of radius about , which passes through . A circle about of radius meets it in exactly two points whenever ; both and qualify. That is circles of area .
Case . The center lies on the circle of radius about , and . Circles of radii and with centers apart meet in two points when , i.e. . Both and qualify: circles of area .
Sum of areas: .
The answer is .
Why this works
Two concentric constraints determine the radius and the distance of the center from , leaving the center free on a circle; the third tangency is another circle for the center to lie on, and two circles generically meet twice. Each valid combination therefore contributes two circles, mirror images across the -axis by symmetry. Counting configurations rather than solving for coordinates is the whole game.
The trap
Considering only circles squeezed inside the annulus (radius 3) and missing the radius-5 circles that enclose the small circle, giving 4 · 9π = 36π or 68π.
Common mistakes
- Considering only circles squeezed inside the annulus (radius 3) and missing the radius-5 circles that enclose the small circle, giving 4 · 9π = 36π or 68π.
- Counting only external tangency to the third circle and forgetting the internally tangent option, halving each case.
Techniques
Split into exhaustive cases and handle each · Exploit symmetry to reduce work or pair up objects