Let be the set of circles in the coordinate plane that are tangent to each of the three circles with equations , , and . What is the sum of the areas of all circles in ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
E
Key insight
Touching both circles centred at the origin forces radius 3 or radius 5. Each size can then touch the third circle in four positions.
Solution
The first two circles are centred at the origin with radii and . The third is centred at with radius . Start with the first two, because they fix the size of the circle we want.
- Where the circle must be. A circle touching both the radius- circle and the radius- circle must sit inside the big one, touching it from the inside. (A circle outside the big one could never reach the small one.) So if it has radius and centre , then .
- Touching the small circle. Either it sits beside the small circle (touching from outside), so , or it wraps around the small circle (touching from inside), so .
- Beside: gives , and .
- Wrapped around: gives , and .
- Now the third circle. Our circle touches the circle around either from outside, so , or by wrapping around it, so . (Our is or , both bigger than , so the small circle cannot wrap around ours.)
- Radius 3. The centre lies on the circle of radius around , which passes through . We need or . On a circle of radius , points at distance from the point on it exist in pairs (one above the -axis, one below) for every between and . So each distance gives centres: circles of area .
- Radius 5. The centre lies on the circle of radius around , and is from . The nearest point of that circle to is away and the farthest is away. We need or , both strictly between and , so again each gives centres: circles of area .
- Add the areas. .
The answer is .
Why this works
Two circles with the same centre decide both the size of a touching circle and how far its centre is from that common centre, so the centre must lie on a known circle. Touching the third circle puts the centre at a fixed distance from another point, which is a second circle, and two circles usually cross at two points. Remember both ways of touching: side by side, and one around the other.
The trap
Only thinking of small circles squeezed between the two round walls (radius 3) and missing the radius-5 circles that wrap around the small circle.
Concise solution
Let be the origin; the first two circles have radii and . A circle of radius with center at distance from tangent to both must lie inside the big circle (a circle outside it cannot reach the small one), so . It is tangent to the small circle either externally, , or by enclosing it, .
- Externally: , so and .
- Enclosing: , so and .
Now impose tangency to the third circle, center , radius : the distance from our center to must be or .
Case . The center lies on the circle of radius about , which passes through . A circle about of radius meets it in exactly two points whenever ; both and qualify. That is circles of area .
Case . The center lies on the circle of radius about , and . Circles of radii and with centers apart meet in two points when , i.e. . Both and qualify: circles of area .
Sum of areas: .
The answer is .
Review in the AoPS books
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 11: Circles
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 17: Analytic Geometry
- Introduction to Counting & Probability, Chapter 2: Basic Counting Techniques (§2.2)
- Introduction to Algebra, Chapter 22: Special Manipulations (§22.3)
Techniques
Split into exhaustive cases and handle each · Exploit symmetry to reduce work or pair up objects