Let be the sum of the first terms of an arithmetic sequence that has a common difference of . The quotient does not depend on . What is ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
D
Key insight
With d = 2, S_n = n(a + n − 1), so S_{3n}/S_n is constant only when a = 1; then S_n = n² and S_20 = 400.
Solution
Let the first term be . With common difference ,
Therefore
Write . The fraction equals when , and otherwise changes with (for and it gives and , which are equal only when ). So .
The sequence is , the odd numbers, and . Hence .
The answer is .
Why this works
A ratio of two linear expressions in is independent of exactly when the numerator is a constant multiple of the denominator; here that forces the constant term to vanish. The result is the classic fact that the sum of the first odd numbers is , which is what makes for every .
Alternative approach
Impose the condition for and : gives . Cross-multiplying: , so . Then .
The trap
Solving for a but then computing S_20 with the wrong formula, e.g. 20 · (first term) + 2 · 20 or forgetting to use d = 2.
Common mistakes
- Solving for a but then computing S_20 with the wrong formula, e.g. 20 · (first term) + 2 · 20 or forgetting to use d = 2.
- Assuming the first term is (the common difference) and getting .
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed · Test small/specific values or special cases to find or verify the answer