What is the maximum number of balls of clay of radius that can completely fit inside a cube of side length assuming the balls can be reshaped but not compressed before they are packed in the cube?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
D
Key insight
The clay can be reshaped, so only the amount of clay matters. Divide the cube's volume 216 by one ball's volume, about 33.5, to get about 6.4.
Solution
1. "Reshaped but not compressed" means you can mold the clay into any shape, but you cannot squeeze it into less space. So the only thing that matters is volume: all the clay together has to fit into the cube's volume.
2. Volume of the cube: .
3. Volume of one ball, using with :
With , this is about .
4. Check how many balls' worth of clay fits:
- balls: , which is less than . They fit.
- balls: , which is more than . They do not fit.
5. So the most is balls.
The answer is .
Why this works
The phrase "can be reshaped" removes all the geometry of packing round balls into a box. What is left is one comparison of volumes. To be sure the rounding of does not matter, check the two nearest whole numbers: balls use about , safely under , and use about , safely over.
Alternative approach
Avoid decimals. The number of balls is at most . Since is less than , and is more than , the answer is between and , so balls fit.
The trap
Thinking of the balls as solid spheres 4 wide that must sit whole inside a 6-wide cube. Only one would fit that way, but the clay can be reshaped.
Concise solution
Because the clay can be reshaped, the only constraint is volume: the total clay volume cannot exceed the cube's volume.
The cube has volume . One ball has volume
The number of balls that fit is
Since , the quotient is between and , so balls fit and a seventh does not.
The answer is .
Review in the AoPS books
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 14: Three-Dimensional Geometry
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 15: Curved Surfaces
Techniques
Bound the quantity above/below or estimate to pin it down · Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed