Let be the set of all positive integer divisors of How many numbers are the product of two distinct elements of
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
Products of two divisors of 2^5 5^5 are the 121 numbers 2^x 5^y, exponents 0 to 10; only four corners force equal divisors.
Solution
, so consists of the numbers with .
A product of two elements of has the form with . There are such numbers, and each one arises: split and with all parts in .
The question requires the two divisors to be distinct. An exponent can be split into two different parts unless (only ) or (only ). So is a product of two distinct divisors as long as at least one of lies strictly between and ; the exceptions are the four "corners" :
Hence numbers qualify. The answer is .
Why this works
Multiplying divisors adds exponents, so the set of all products is a grid of exponent pairs, easy to count. The "distinct" condition is then a small correction: a product is forced to use equal factors only when both exponents are at an extreme. Count the whole grid, then subtract the genuinely degenerate points.
The trap
Answering 121 by forgetting the word 'distinct', or subtracting only the two obvious cases 1 and 10^10 to get 119.
Common mistakes
- Answering 121 by forgetting the word 'distinct', or subtracting only the two obvious cases 1 and 10^10 to get 119.
- Excluding every product of the form (all squares), forgetting that most perfect-square products can also be written with two different divisors.
Techniques
Map the objects to something easier to count · Count the complement and subtract from the total