Two jars each contain the same number of marbles, and every marble is either blue or green. In Jar the ratio of blue to green marbles is , and the ratio of blue to green marbles in Jar is . There are green marbles in all. How many more blue marbles are in Jar than in Jar ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
A
Key insight
Each jar holds 90k marbles, so the greens are 9k + 10k = 19k = 95 and the blue difference is 81k - 80k = k = 5.
Solution
Let each jar hold marbles. In Jar the greens are of the marbles, and in Jar they are . Both fractions must be whole numbers, so is a multiple of ; write .
- Jar : green, blue.
- Jar : green, blue.
Total green: , so (each jar holds marbles).
Blue difference: .
The answer is .
Why this works
A ratio says the greens are of the jar, and says ; the shared jar size is the link between the two jars. Introducing one scaling variable for the common size turns both ratios into integer counts and reduces the problem to a single equation. The requested difference is just the coefficient of that variable.
Alternative approach
Directly: gives , so . Blue counts are and , differing by .
The trap
Applying the ratios to the total green count (95) instead of to each jar, or forgetting that both jars hold the same number of marbles.
Common mistakes
- Applying the ratios to the total green count (95) instead of to each jar, or forgetting that both jars hold the same number of marbles.
- Answering the difference in green marbles ( happens to match here) by luck, or reporting 's multiple such as without checking which quantity was asked.
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed