In a given plane, points and are units apart. How many points are there in the plane such that the perimeter of is units and the area of is square units?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
A
Key insight
Area 100 on base 10 needs height 20, but with AC + BC = 40 the height is largest when AC = BC = 20, giving sqrt(375) < 20.
Solution
The perimeter condition gives . The area condition gives , so must be at height above line .
Among all points with , the one farthest from line is the symmetric one with (moving off the perpendicular bisector while keeping the sum fixed lowers it, since the locus is an ellipse with foci and and its highest point is on the minor axis). In that position the height is
So no point with reaches height , and the maximum possible area is . No such exists.
The answer is .
Why this works
Two constraints on (a perimeter and an area) normally intersect in finitely many points, but only if each is achievable given the other. Fixing bounds how far can be from , and the isosceles configuration is the extreme case. When a counting question offers as a choice, check feasibility before counting.
The trap
Assuming a triangle with the given perimeter and area exists and answering 2 or 4 by symmetry, without checking whether height 20 is reachable.
Common mistakes
- Assuming a triangle with the given perimeter and area exists and answering 2 or 4 by symmetry, without checking whether height 20 is reachable.
- Comparing the required height with and concluding it works, forgetting that the height is a leg, shorter than the hypotenuse .
Techniques
Bound the quantity above/below or estimate to pin it down · Consider the largest/smallest element or boundary case