The figure below shows line with a regular, infinite, recurring pattern of squares and line segments.
How many of the following four kinds of rigid motion transformations of the plane in which this figure is drawn, other than the identity transformation, will transform this figure into itself?
- some rotation around a point of line
- some translation in the direction parallel to line
- the reflection across line
- some reflection across a line perpendicular to line
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
Lower squares are offset with reversed tails, so a half-turn about a point of the line and a translation by one period work; both reflections fail.
Solution
Describe the pattern precisely. Above , unit squares sit on the line with a short diagonal tail leaving the top-right corner toward the upper right. Below , congruent squares hang from the line, shifted half a period to the right, with a tail leaving the bottom-left corner toward the lower left. The whole picture repeats every units along .
- Translation parallel to by units: the pattern repeats, so this works.
- Rotation by about a point of midway between an upper square and the next lower square: a half-turn sends "square above, tail up-right from the top-right corner" to "square below, tail down-left from the bottom-left corner," which is exactly how the lower squares look, and the offset matches. This works.
- Reflection across : an upper square would land directly below itself, but the lower squares are shifted, and the tail would point down-right instead of down-left. Fails.
- Reflection across a line perpendicular to : every tail slanting up-right becomes one slanting up-left, and no tail in the figure does that. Fails.
Two of the four motions preserve the figure.
The answer is .
Why this works
Test each candidate motion on the smallest distinctive detail, here the little tails: a reflection reverses the slant of a tail while a half-turn reverses it twice and keeps it. Combined with the half-period offset of the lower row, this pins down which motions are symmetries. The figure is a frieze with a rotation and translations but no mirror lines.
The trap
Assuming the reflection across the line works because there are squares on both sides, without checking that the lower squares are shifted and their tails reversed.
Common mistakes
- Assuming the reflection across the line works because there are squares on both sides, without checking that the lower squares are shifted and their tails reversed.
- Dismissing rotation because the figure "has a direction" along the line; a half-turn reverses that direction on both rows at once, which is consistent with the picture.
Techniques
Organized listing / direct enumeration · Exploit symmetry to reduce work or pair up objects