Real numbers and are chosen independently and uniformly at random from the interval . Which of the following numbers is closest to the probability that and are the side lengths of an obtuse triangle?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
With 1 the longest side, the conditions are x + y > 1 and x^2 + y^2 < 1: a quarter disk minus a triangle, area pi/4 - 1/2.
Solution
Since , the side of length is the longest, so it is opposite the largest angle. Two conditions are needed:
- A triangle exists: the two shorter sides must exceed the longest, (the other two inequalities hold automatically).
- The angle opposite the side is obtuse: .
In the unit square of all , the second condition is the interior of the quarter disk of radius centered at the origin, area . The first condition removes the triangle below the line , which has area and lies entirely inside that quarter disk. The favorable region is therefore the quarter disk with the triangle cut out:
The closest choice is , so the answer is .
Why this works
Uniform random pairs turn probability into area in the unit square, and each geometric condition becomes a curve: the triangle inequality is a line, the obtuse condition is a circle. Identifying the longest side first is what keeps the problem to a single case; then the region is a standard shape minus another.
Alternative approach
The choices are spread out, so a rough estimate suffices: the quarter disk has area about ; the region below is exactly half the square, , and it lies inside the quarter disk, so the answer is just under . Any answer near rules out everything but (C).
The trap
Dropping the triangle inequality and answering pi/4 = 0.79, or reversing the obtuse condition to x^2 + y^2 > 1 and getting 0.21.
Common mistakes
- Dropping the triangle inequality and answering pi/4 = 0.79, or reversing the obtuse condition to x^2 + y^2 > 1 and getting 0.21.
- Treating or as a possible longest side; with both at most , the side is always longest, so only one obtuse condition applies.
Techniques
Cut the figure into known shapes (triangles, rectangles, sectors)