What is the largest number of solid by by blocks that can fit in a by by box?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
Volume allows at most 4 blocks, since 5 blocks need 20 cubic inches and the box has 18. Three flat blocks plus one on its side fit.
Solution
This is a "largest number" question, so it has two halves: show that some number of blocks fits, then show that one more cannot.
Part 1: five blocks cannot fit.
- The box has volume cubic inches.
- Each block has volume cubic inches.
- Five blocks would need cubic inches, more than the box has. So at most blocks fit.
Part 2: four blocks do fit.
- Think of the box as inches wide, inches deep and inches tall.
- Lay a block flat: wide, deep, tall. Stack three of them in the left part of the box. Together they fill a space wide, deep and tall.
- What is left is a slab inch wide, deep and tall.
- Turn the fourth block on its side so it is wide, deep and tall. It fits in the slab, with inch of height to spare.
Four blocks fit and five cannot, so the answer is .
Why this works
Packing questions always have two halves: a volume count that says "no more than this," and an actual arrangement that reaches that number. When the two agree, you are done. The blocks do not all have to face the same way; turning one of them is often what uses up the leftover space.
The trap
Stacking three blocks flat and stopping at 3, without noticing the leftover 1 by 2 by 3 space holds a fourth block turned on its side.
Concise solution
Upper bound: the box has volume cubic inches and each block has volume . Since , at most blocks fit.
Construction: think of the box as wide, deep, tall. Lay a block flat so its face covers a wide by deep footprint and it is tall; stack three of these to fill a column. The remaining space is a slab. Stand the fourth block on its edge: wide, deep, tall. It fits in the slab with one inch of height to spare.
Four blocks fit and five cannot, so the answer is .
Review in the AoPS books
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 14: Three-Dimensional Geometry
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 15: Curved Surfaces
Techniques
Bound the quantity above/below or estimate to pin it down