At a gathering of people, there are people who all know each other and people who know no one. People who know each other hug, and people who do not know each other shake hands. How many handshakes occur?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
A handshake happens exactly when at least one of the pair is a stranger: 10 times 20 mixed pairs plus C(10,2) stranger-stranger pairs.
Solution
The only pairs who know each other are pairs drawn from the group of . Every other pair shakes hands, so a handshake occurs exactly when the pair contains at least one of the strangers.
Pairs with one stranger and one member of the : .
Pairs of two strangers: .
Total handshakes: .
The answer is .
Why this works
Split the pairs by how many strangers they contain. Each pair is either a hug (both in the acquainted group) or a handshake (everything else), so the classification is exhaustive and non-overlapping. Counting "one from each group" is a product; counting "two from the same group" is a combination.
Alternative approach
Complementary counting: there are pairs altogether, and of them hug. The rest shake hands: .
The trap
Forgetting that the 10 strangers also shake hands with each other, giving only 200, or counting each handshake twice, giving 490.
Common mistakes
- Forgetting that the 10 strangers also shake hands with each other, giving only 200, or counting each handshake twice, giving 490.
- Using , which counts each stranger-stranger handshake twice.
Techniques
Count the complement and subtract from the total · Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed