A set of teams held a round-robin tournament in which every team played every other team exactly once. Every team won games and lost games; there were no ties. How many sets of three teams were there in which beat , beat , and beat
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
A
Key insight
There are 21 teams; a triple is non-cyclic iff one team beat the other two, and each team supplies C(10,2) such triples, so C(21,3) - 21*45 = 385.
Solution
Each team played games, one against every other team, so there are teams and sets of three teams.
Look at the three games inside any set of three teams. Either the results form a cycle ( beats , beats , beats ), or they do not; and if they do not, then some team won both of its games in the set. Exactly one team can do so (two teams cannot both beat each other), so each non-cyclic triple is identified by its dominant team together with two of that team's victims.
Count non-cyclic triples by dominant team: each of the teams beat others, giving pairs of victims, for
non-cyclic triples in total.
The cyclic triples are what remain:
The answer is .
Why this works
Cycles are hard to count directly but their complement has a clean structure: a non-cyclic triple has a unique "winner of the triple," and choosing that winner plus two of its victims is a bijection with such triples. The uniform record ( wins each) makes the count the same for every team. This is a standard tournament argument: transitive triples , cyclic triples .
The trap
Reporting the number of transitive triples, 945 (choice C), or the total number of triples, 1330 (choice E), instead of their difference.
Common mistakes
- Reporting the number of transitive triples, (choice C), or the total number of triples, (choice E), instead of their difference.
- Using teams (forgetting that a team does not play itself), which gives (choice D) and a wrong count.
Techniques
Map the objects to something easier to count · Count the complement and subtract from the total