Ximena lists the whole numbers through once. Emilio copies Ximena's numbers, replacing each occurrence of the digit by the digit . Ximena adds her numbers and Emilio adds his numbers. How much larger is Ximena's sum than Emilio's?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
D
Key insight
Each replaced units digit 2 lowers the sum by 1 and each replaced tens digit 2 lowers it by 10; count the digit positions, not the numbers.
Solution
Work digit by digit. Changing a to a in the units place lowers a number by ; changing a to a in the tens place lowers it by .
Units-place s among through : the numbers , , , three of them. Total loss: .
Tens-place s: the numbers through , ten of them. Total loss: .
(The number appears in both counts, and correctly so: it loses .)
Ximena's sum exceeds Emilio's by . The answer is .
Why this works
Place value makes the effect of a digit change independent of the rest of the number, so the total difference is a sum over digit positions. Count occurrences of the digit in each place separately and weight by the place value; do not try to list the modified numbers.
The trap
Counting only the units-digit 2s (giving 3) or treating every number containing a 2 as losing exactly 1 or 10, and missing that 22 loses 11.
Common mistakes
- Counting only the units-digit 2s (giving 3) or treating every number containing a 2 as losing exactly 1 or 10, and missing that 22 loses 11.
- Counting the tens-place s as through ( numbers) instead of through , which gives .
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed