For some particular value of , when is expanded and like terms are combined, the resulting expression contains exactly terms that include all four variables and , each to some positive power. What is ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
All-four-variables terms are solutions of i+j+k+l+m = N with i,j,k,l >= 1 and m >= 0 for the 1; stars and bars gives C(N,4).
Solution
After combining like terms, each distinct term is where the exponents record how many of the factors contributed , , , , or . If factors contributed the , then
We want the terms with . Give each of one forced unit: set , etc. Then with all five variables nonnegative. By stars and bars the number of solutions is
Set . Since , we get . (The function is increasing, so this is the only solution.)
The answer is .
Why this works
Counting distinct monomials in an expansion is counting exponent tuples, and the constant term acts as a fifth variable that absorbs whatever degree is left over. Forcing positive exponents is the standard "hand out one unit first" reduction to nonnegative stars and bars. The factorization is a strong hint toward .
Alternative approach
Test the choices directly with : , , . Only works.
The trap
Dropping the constant 1 from the count (treating the exponents as summing to exactly N with no slack), which gives C(N-1, 3) and no matching choice.
Common mistakes
- Dropping the constant 1 from the count (treating the exponents as summing to exactly N with no slack), which gives C(N-1, 3) and no matching choice.
- Also forcing the exponent of to be positive, which yields and , not among the choices.
Techniques
Map the objects to something easier to count · Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed