Isaac has written down one integer two times and another integer three times. The sum of the five numbers is , and one of the numbers is What is the other number?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
A
Key insight
If 28 were written twice the other number would be 44/3, not an integer; so 28 is written three times and the other is 8.
Solution
Let be the integer written twice and the integer written three times, so . The number is either or .
If : then , so , which is not an integer. Rejected.
If : then , so . This is an integer, and checks.
The answer is .
Why this works
The statement is deliberately ambiguous about which role plays, so test both. The word "integer" is the deciding constraint: one case produces a fraction and dies. Whenever a word problem says "integer," expect divisibility to eliminate a case.
The trap
Assuming 28 is the number written twice, getting 44/3 = 14.67, and choosing 14 or 15 as 'close enough'.
Common mistakes
- Assuming 28 is the number written twice, getting 44/3 = 14.67, and choosing 14 or 15 as 'close enough'.
- Writing with the roles swapped and not noticing that both cases then fail, or forgetting to check the arithmetic .
Techniques
Test small/specific values or special cases to find or verify the answer