What is the sign and units digit of the product of all the odd negative integers strictly greater than ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
There are 1007 factors, an odd count, so the product is negative; it contains the factor -5 and only odd factors, so it ends in 5.
Solution
The integers in question are (not , since "strictly greater"). Writing them as for , there are of them.
Sign: each factor is negative and there are factors, an odd number, so the product is negative.
Units digit: the absolute value is . This product is odd (all factors odd) and divisible by (it contains the factor ). An odd multiple of ends in .
So the product is negative and ends in :
Why this works
Two independent invariants settle the two questions. The sign of a product is determined by the parity of the number of negative factors, and a units digit is a mod- fact: divisible by pins the last digit to or , and oddness picks . No multiplication is needed at all.
The trap
Miscounting the factors as 1008 (including -2015 or an off-by-one) and calling the product positive, choice (D).
Common mistakes
- Miscounting the factors as 1008 (including or an off-by-one) and calling the product positive, choice (D).
- Thinking a product of many numbers "must" end in (choice (E)); that needs a factor of , and every factor here is odd.
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed · Use an invariant, parity, or coloring argument