In the addition shown below and are distinct digits. How many different values are possible for ?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
The tens and thousands columns force C = 0 with no carries, so D = A + B for distinct nonzero A, B, giving D from 3 to 9.
Solution
Work column by column from the right, tracking carries.
Units: ends in ; call the carry .
Tens: ends in , so is or . Either and , or and .
If , : then and the tens column produces a carry of . The hundreds column reads , which ends in , not . Impossible.
If , : then with no carry, the tens column is with no carry, the hundreds column is again with no carry, the thousands column is , and the ten-thousands column is . Everything is consistent.
So the only requirement is where , are distinct digits, both nonzero (they differ from ), and . Since , the sum automatically differs from both. The possible sums range from up to , and every value is achievable (for example ).
That is values, so the answer is .
Why this works
In a cryptarithm, columns where the same letter appears in a summand and the sum (here in the tens place, in the thousands place) are the most informative: they force the other addend plus the carry to be or . Resolving those columns first collapses the whole problem to one simple equation.
The trap
Forgetting that D = A + B needs two distinct nonzero digits, so D = 1 and D = 2 are impossible; answering 8 or 9.
Common mistakes
- Forgetting that D = A + B needs two distinct nonzero digits, so D = 1 and D = 2 are impossible; answering 8 or 9.
- Ignoring the branch entirely (correct by luck) or, worse, accepting it and adding extra values of .
Techniques
Split into exhaustive cases and handle each · Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed