A customer who intends to purchase an appliance has three coupons, only one of which may be used:
Coupon 1: off the listed price if the listed price is at least
Coupon 2: off the listed price if the listed price is at least
Coupon 3: off the amount by which the listed price exceeds
For which of the following listed prices will coupon offer a greater price reduction than either coupon or coupon ?
- A)
$179.95
- B)
$199.95
- C)
$219.95
- D)
$239.95
- E)
$259.95
Answer
C
Key insight
Coupon 1 beats coupon 2 when 0.1P > 20 (P > 200) and beats coupon 3 when 0.1P > 0.18(P - 100) (P < 225); only 219.95 fits.
Solution
Let the listed price be ; every choice exceeds , so all three coupons apply. The savings are
Coupon 1 must beat coupon 2:
Coupon 1 must beat coupon 3:
So the price must satisfy . Among the choices only lies in that range.
The answer is .
Why this works
A percentage discount grows with the price while a flat discount does not, and a discount on the excess over grows faster than once the price is large enough. Translating each comparison into a linear inequality yields a window for ; the lower bound comes from the flat coupon and the upper bound from the steeper coupon.
Alternative approach
Test the choices directly. At : coupon 1 saves , coupon 2 saves , coupon 3 saves . At coupon 3 saves about , beating coupon 1's ; at coupon 1 saves under .
The trap
Comparing the final prices incorrectly, or only checking coupon 1 against coupon 2 and picking the first choice above 200.
Common mistakes
- Comparing the final prices incorrectly, or only checking coupon 1 against coupon 2 and picking the first choice above 200.
- Computing coupon 3 as of the whole price instead of of the amount over .
Techniques
Use the answer choices (mod checks, size, form) to eliminate or select · Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed