All 20 diagonals are drawn in a regular octagon. At how many distinct points in the interior of the octagon (not on the boundary) do two or more diagonals intersect?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
A
Key insight
Every 4 vertices give one crossing pair, C(8,4) = 70, but the center is counted 6 times and eight triple points are counted 3 times each.
Solution
Two diagonals cross inside the octagon exactly when their four endpoints alternate around the boundary, and any vertices determine exactly one such crossing pair. So there are crossing pairs of diagonals. If no three diagonals met at a point, the answer would be ; in a regular octagon some do, and those points are over-counted.
Label the vertices through in order.
The center. The four long diagonals , , , all pass through the center. Those account for crossing pairs but only point: subtract .
Triple points. Take a long diagonal, say , and the two diagonals and , which are mirror images of each other across the line . Mirror-image segments cross on the mirror line, and since and do cross (their endpoints alternate: ), all three diagonals pass through one point. Each long diagonal carries two such points (one on each side of the center, using and for ), giving triple points. Each is counted times but is point: subtract per point, in all.
No other concurrences occur. Therefore the number of distinct interior intersection points is
The answer is .
Why this works
The bijection " vertices one crossing pair" is the standard way to count diagonal intersections, and is exact for polygons in general position. Regular polygons break general position through symmetry: mirror-image diagonals must meet on the axis, which is where the extra concurrences come from. The correction for a point where diagonals meet is .
Alternative approach
Count by direct drawing along one long diagonal: on the interior points, in order, are the two triple points and the center, plus ordinary crossings with the remaining diagonals. Combined with the octagon's -fold symmetry this reproduces , but it is easy to lose track; the correction method is more reliable. Choice (C) is the general-position count and can be ruled out immediately once you notice the four long diagonals share the center.
The trap
Answering 70 by assuming no three diagonals are concurrent; the regular octagon has concurrency at the center and at eight other points.
Common mistakes
- Answering 70 by assuming no three diagonals are concurrent; the regular octagon has concurrency at the center and at eight other points.
- Fixing only the center (, choice B) and missing the eight triple points.
Techniques
Map the objects to something easier to count · Exploit symmetry to reduce work or pair up objects