It takes Clea 60 seconds to walk down an escalator when it is not operating, and only 24 seconds to walk down the escalator when it is operating. How many seconds does it take Clea to ride down the operating escalator when she just stands on it?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
Rates add: walking covers 1/60 of the escalator per second and walking-plus-riding 1/24, so riding alone covers 1/24 - 1/60 = 1/40 per second.
Solution
Measure distance in "escalator lengths." Walking on a stopped escalator, Clea covers the whole length in seconds, so her walking speed is length per second.
Walking on the moving escalator, her speed relative to the ground is her walking speed plus the escalator's speed, and she covers the length in seconds: combined speed .
Therefore the escalator's own speed is
length per second. Standing still, she needs seconds.
The answer is .
Why this works
When two motions act together, their speeds add, so convert each given time into a rate (fraction of the job per second), do the arithmetic on rates, then convert back. This is the same structure as "work" problems: two workers together take minutes, one alone takes , how long for the other. Choosing the length as unit (or units to avoid fractions) keeps the numbers clean.
Alternative approach
Let the escalator be steps long. Clea walks steps per second. With the escalator running she moves steps per second, so the escalator contributes steps per second, and seconds.
The trap
Subtracting the times (60 - 24 = 36) instead of the rates; rates add, times do not.
Common mistakes
- Subtracting the times (60 - 24 = 36) instead of the rates; rates add, times do not.
- Averaging and to get , or adding the rates as if the escalator's speed were the combined speed.
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed