It takes Clea 60 seconds to walk down an escalator when it is not operating, and only 24 seconds to walk down the escalator when it is operating. How many seconds does it take Clea to ride down the operating escalator when she just stands on it?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
Speeds add, not times. Pretend the escalator has 120 steps: Clea walks 2 steps per second, and with the escalator she moves 5, so the escalator alone moves 3.
Solution
- Pick a length for the escalator that both and divide evenly. works, so pretend the escalator is steps long.
- On the stopped escalator Clea walks steps in seconds. Her walking speed is steps per second.
- On the moving escalator she covers steps in seconds, which is steps per second.
- That is her walking speed plus the escalator's speed. So the escalator by itself moves steps per second.
- If she just stands, only the escalator moves her: seconds.
The answer is .
Why this works
When two motions work together, their speeds add. So turn each time into a speed, do the adding or subtracting with speeds, and turn the answer back into a time at the end. This is the same as "work" problems: if Clea and the escalator together finish the job in seconds and Clea alone takes , how long does the escalator take alone?
Alternative approach
Use fractions of the escalator instead. Walking alone, Clea covers of it each second. Walking on the moving escalator, she covers each second. The escalator's share is
of the escalator per second, so it takes seconds alone.
The trap
Subtracting the times, 60 - 24 = 36, and choosing (A). Times do not add or subtract; speeds do.
Concise solution
Measure distance in "escalator lengths." Walking on a stopped escalator, Clea covers the whole length in seconds, so her walking speed is length per second.
Walking on the moving escalator, her speed relative to the ground is her walking speed plus the escalator's speed, and she covers the length in seconds: combined speed .
Therefore the escalator's own speed is
length per second. Standing still, she needs seconds.
The answer is .
Review in the AoPS books
- Introduction to Algebra, Chapter 3: One-Variable Linear Equations (§3.3, §3.4)
- Introduction to Algebra, Chapter 6: Ratios and Percents
- Introduction to Algebra, Chapter 7: Proportion (§7.4)
- Prealgebra, Chapter 13: Data and Statistics (§13.1)
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed