A month with days has the same number of Mondays and Wednesdays. How many of the seven days of the week could be the first day of this month?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
31 days is four weeks plus 3, so only the first three weekdays occur five times; Monday and Wednesday must both be in or both out of that block.
Solution
Since , every weekday occurs four times, and the weekdays of days , which are the same as days , occur a fifth time. So the first day and the two days after it appear five times; the other four weekdays appear four times.
Monday and Wednesday have equal counts exactly when the three-day block (with the starting weekday) contains both of them or neither.
- Both: the block must be Mon, Tue, Wed, so Monday.
- Neither: the block must avoid Monday and Wednesday. Checking each start, Thu-Fri-Sat and Fri-Sat-Sun work; Sat-Sun-Mon, Sun-Mon-Tue, Tue-Wed-Thu, and Wed-Thu-Fri each contain one of the two days.
That gives possible starting days: Monday, Thursday, Friday.
The answer is .
Why this works
A month's weekday counts depend only on the remainder of its length mod : the leftover days are the ones that get an extra occurrence. Turning "same number of Mondays and Wednesdays" into a statement about a three-day window makes the check a quick list of seven cases.
The trap
Only finding the start day Monday (both days occur five times) and forgetting the starts where neither Monday nor Wednesday gets a fifth occurrence.
Common mistakes
- Only finding the start day Monday (both days occur five times) and forgetting the starts where neither Monday nor Wednesday gets a fifth occurrence.
- Counting Saturday as a valid start: the block Sat-Sun-Mon gives Monday five occurrences but Wednesday only four.
Techniques
Organized listing / direct enumeration