A square of side length and a circle of radius share the same center. What is the area inside the circle, but outside the square?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
The circle crosses each side at a 60-degree central angle (cos of half-angle is (1/2)/(sqrt3/3) = sqrt3/2), so the four bulges are four 60-degree circular segments.
Solution
Let and the common center. Each side of the square is at distance from ; since , the circle pokes out through each side but does not reach the corners. The desired region is four congruent circular segments.
Consider one side and let be the points where the circle crosses it. In right triangle from to the midpoint of the side to , the leg along the perpendicular is and the hypotenuse is , so
an angle of . Hence , and triangle is equilateral with side .
Segment area sector triangle:
Four segments: .
The answer is .
Why this works
Overlap of a circle and a polygon is always a sum of circular segments, each equal to a sector minus an isosceles triangle. The radius was chosen so that the half-angle is a -- angle; whenever a distance-to-radius ratio is , or , expect a special angle.
Alternative approach
Estimate: the circle's area is , only slightly more than the square's , and most of the circle lies inside. The answer must be small but positive: (B) fits, while (C) and (D) are plausible only if you compute; (A) ignores the square's corners sticking out.
The trap
Subtracting the whole square from the circle (the circle does not contain the square), or using a 30-degree angle for the segment.
Common mistakes
- Subtracting the whole square from the circle (the circle does not contain the square), or using a 30-degree angle for the segment.
- Computing the triangle inside the sector with base instead of using the equilateral triangle of side , or forgetting to multiply the segment by .
Techniques
Cut the figure into known shapes (triangles, rectangles, sectors) · Exploit symmetry to reduce work or pair up objects