Shelby drives her scooter at a speed of miles per hour if it is not raining, and miles per hour if it is raining. Today she drove in the sun in the morning and in the rain in the evening, for a total of miles in minutes. How many minutes did she drive in the rain?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
Work in miles per minute: 1/2 mile per minute in sun and 1/3 in rain; with t rain minutes, (40 - t)/2 + t/3 = 16.
Solution
Convert the speeds to miles per minute: mph is mile per minute and mph is mile per minute.
Let be the number of minutes in the rain, so she spent minutes in the sun. Total distance:
Multiply by : , so and .
Check: sunny minutes cover miles and rainy minutes cover miles, total miles.
The answer is .
Why this works
Two-rate trips are a single linear equation once the unknown is chosen well: let the unknown be the quantity asked for, express the other time as the remainder, and add the distances. Converting rates to the same time unit as the data (minutes) avoids fractions of an hour.
Alternative approach
If all minutes were in the sun she would cover miles, too many. Each minute switched to rain loses mile, so minutes must be rainy.
The trap
Mixing hours and minutes, e.g. using 40 as the total time in hours, or solving for the sunny minutes (16) and stopping.
Common mistakes
- Mixing hours and minutes, e.g. using 40 as the total time in hours, or solving for the sunny minutes (16) and stopping.
- Averaging the two speeds to mph and assuming equal times, which does not use the -mile constraint.
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed