Tyrone had marbles and Eric had marbles. Tyrone then gave some of his marbles to Eric so that Tyrone ended with twice as many marbles as Eric. How many marbles did Tyrone give to Eric?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
D
Key insight
The total 108 marbles is fixed, so Tyrone ends with 72 and Eric with 36; Tyrone gave away 97 - 72 = 25.
Solution
Giving marbles back and forth does not change the total, which is .
At the end Tyrone has twice as many as Eric, so the marbles split in the ratio : Eric has and Tyrone has .
Tyrone therefore gave away marbles (equivalently, Eric gained ).
The answer is .
Why this works
When objects are transferred between two people, the total is an invariant. A final ratio then determines both final amounts directly, and the transfer is just the difference from the start. This avoids setting up and solving an equation in the unknown transfer, though works just as well.
The trap
Solving 97 - x = 2 * 11 (ignoring that Eric also gains the marbles) and getting 75, or answering Eric's final count.
Common mistakes
- Solving 97 - x = 2 * 11 (ignoring that Eric also gains the marbles) and getting 75, or answering Eric's final count.
- Sign slip in , e.g. writing instead of .
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed