Each face of a cube is given a single narrow stripe painted from the center of one edge to the center of the opposite edge. The choice of the edge pairing is made at random and independently for each face. What is the probability that there is a continuous stripe encircling the cube?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
An encircling stripe is a belt of four faces around one of three axes, each forced; the other two faces are free, and belts cannot coexist: 12/64.
Solution
Each face has possible stripes, so there are equally likely paintings.
A stripe on a face runs parallel to one pair of the cube's axes; think of each stripe as passing through the centers of two opposite edges of that face. A continuous loop around the cube must cross exactly four faces forming a belt: the four faces surrounding one axis. There are belts, one for each axis (top-bottom, left-right, front-back).
For the loop to exist on a given belt, each of its four faces must have its stripe running "along the belt," which is exactly one of that face's two options. That is choice on each of faces. The two faces not on the belt (the ends of the axis) can be painted either way: choices. So each belt is completed in of the paintings.
Can two different belts be completed at once? Any two belts share two faces, and on a shared face the two belts need stripes in perpendicular directions. A face has only one stripe, so no painting completes two belts. The three cases are disjoint, and the number of good paintings is .
The probability is .
The answer is .
Why this works
Identify the structures that satisfy the condition (belts), count how many paintings realize each, and confirm they are mutually exclusive before adding. The "free faces" factor is the classic omission: faces the condition does not mention still contribute a multiplier to the count.
Alternative approach
Probability version: fix a belt; its four faces are each correct with probability , so the belt forms with probability . The three belt events are disjoint, so the total is .
The trap
Forgetting the 2 x 2 = 4 free choices on the two faces outside the belt, which gives 3/64, or double-counting configurations with two belts, which cannot happen.
Common mistakes
- Forgetting the 2 x 2 = 4 free choices on the two faces outside the belt, which gives 3/64, or double-counting configurations with two belts, which cannot happen.
- Multiplying by (one per face) instead of by (one per axis), giving .
Techniques
Split into exhaustive cases and handle each · Exploit symmetry to reduce work or pair up objects