Andrea and Lauren are kilometers apart. They bike toward one another with Andrea traveling three times as fast as Lauren, and the distance between them decreasing at a rate of kilometer per minute. After minutes, Andrea stops biking because of a flat tire and waits for Lauren. After how many minutes from the time they started to bike does Lauren reach Andrea?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
D
Key insight
The 1 km/min closing rate splits 3:1, so Lauren rides 1/4 km/min; after 5 minutes 15 km remain and Lauren alone needs 60 more minutes.
Solution
Let Lauren's speed be km/min; Andrea's is . Approaching each other, the gap closes at km/min, so
In the first minutes the gap shrinks by km, leaving km between them.
After Andrea stops, only Lauren moves, at km/min. Covering km takes
Total time from the start: minutes.
The answer is .
Why this works
The closing rate is the sum of the two speeds, and a speed ratio splits that rate into and . The problem has two phases with different rates; track the remaining distance at the phase change, then apply distance rate time once more. Note that Andrea's individual speed is never needed after the split.
The trap
Forgetting that Andrea stops and using the combined closing rate for the whole 20 km, which gives 20 minutes.
Common mistakes
- Forgetting that Andrea stops and using the combined closing rate for the whole 20 km, which gives 20 minutes.
- Answering (the second phase only) and forgetting to add the first minutes, or using Andrea's speed for Lauren.
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed