Circle has radius . Circle has an integer radius and remains internally tangent to circle as it rolls once around the circumference of circle . The two circles have the same points of tangency at the beginning and end of circle 's trip. How many possible values can have?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
Rolling without slipping, the same point of B touches again only if r divides 100; 100 has 9 divisors, and r < 100 removes one.
Solution
As circle rolls without slipping, the arc of it has covered always equals the arc of that has been in contact. One trip around uses up arc length on , so the same total arc of has touched .
The same point of is back at the contact point exactly when this arc is a whole number of 's circumferences:
i.e. divides .
has positive divisors: . The condition removes , leaving values.
The answer is .
Why this works
The geometry collapses to one sentence: rolling matches arc lengths, so "same point touching again" is a divisibility condition on circumferences, and circumference is proportional to radius. After that it is counting divisors, with a careful reading of the strict inequality .
The trap
Counting all 9 divisors of 100 and forgetting the condition r < 100 excludes r = 100, or believing the answer must be 50 or 90.
Common mistakes
- Counting all 9 divisors of 100 and forgetting the condition r < 100 excludes r = 100, or believing the answer must be 50 or 90.
- Worrying about the rotation of circle relative to the fixed frame (which differs by one turn for internal rolling); only the contact arc matters here.
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed