Michael walks at the rate of feet per second on a long straight path. Trash pails are located every feet along the path. A garbage truck travels at feet per second in the same direction as Michael and stops for seconds at each pail. As Michael passes a pail, he notices the truck ahead of him just leaving the next pail. How many times will Michael and the truck meet?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
Track the truck's lead over each 50-second cycle: up 100 while driving, down 150 while stopped, so it drifts down 50 per cycle and crosses zero finitely often.
Solution
Let be the truck's lead over Michael, in feet. At , .
The truck's motion repeats every seconds: it drives feet in seconds, then stops for seconds. While driving, the truck gains ft/s on Michael, so rises by ; while stopped, Michael closes at ft/s, so falls by . Net change per cycle: .
Record at the end of each drive and each stop:
| cycle | after drive | after stop |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||
| 2 | ||
| 3 | ||
| 4 | ||
| 5 | ||
| 6 | ||
| 7 | ||
| 8 |
Meetings are the moments . In cycle 4, reaches exactly as the stop ends (meeting 1). In cycle 5, goes from down through to (meeting 2). In cycle 6, the drive takes from up through to (meeting 3), and the stop takes it back down through to (meeting 4). In cycle 7, the drive brings from up to exactly (meeting 5), after which the truck stops and Michael pulls ahead. From then on, each drive raises by only while starts at or lower, so stays negative forever.
They meet times. The answer is .
Why this works
Two movers meet whenever their separation is zero, so the problem is about the sign changes of a piecewise-linear function with a repeating pattern and a steady downward drift. Bookkeeping the gap at the turning points of each cycle captures every crossing, including the two "grazing" meetings where the gap touches zero at a cycle boundary. Once the peaks of drop below zero, no further meetings are possible.
Alternative approach
Plot distance versus time: Michael is a line of slope ; the truck is a staircase of slope- segments and horizontal rests. Counting the intersections of the line with the staircase, including tangential touches at corners, gives .
The trap
Assuming that once Michael catches the truck he stays ahead, or missing the two meetings where the gap only touches zero at the end of a stop or a drive.
Common mistakes
- Assuming that once Michael catches the truck he stays ahead, or missing the two meetings where the gap only touches zero at the end of a stop or a drive.
- Counting the drift of feet per cycle and answering , which ignores the back-and-forth within each cycle.
Techniques
Organized listing / direct enumeration · Compute small cases, spot the pattern, generalize