Some boys and girls are having a car wash to raise money for a class trip to China. Initially of the group are girls. Shortly thereafter two girls leave and two boys arrive, and then of the group are girls. How many girls were initially in the group?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
The group size never changes, so the drop from 40% to 30% of the same total equals the two girls who left: 10% of the group is 2.
Solution
Let be the number of people in the group. Two girls leave and two boys arrive, so does not change.
Initially there are girls; afterward there are girls, and this is of the same group:
The initial number of girls is .
Check: girls out of is ; after the swap, girls out of is .
The answer is .
Why this works
Percentages are only comparable when you know what they are percentages of. Noticing that the total is unchanged lets the two percentages be subtracted directly: a percentage-point drop equals two people, so the group has people. Look for the invariant quantity before writing any equation.
Alternative approach
Test the choices. With girls at the group has people; after the swap . The other choices give group sizes , and none produce after removing two girls.
The trap
Changing the group total after the swap (it stays the same since two leave and two arrive) or reporting the final number of girls, 6.
Common mistakes
- Changing the group total after the swap (it stays the same since two leave and two arrive) or reporting the final number of girls, 6.
- Setting or similar, as if the group shrank by two.
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed