The numbers from to are placed at the vertices of a cube in such a manner that the sum of the four numbers on each face is the same. What is this common sum?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
C
Key insight
Two opposite faces use every vertex exactly once, so two face sums equal 1 + 2 + ... + 8 = 36 and each face sums to 18.
Solution
Call the common face sum . Take any face and the face opposite it. Those two faces share no vertices, and between them they use all vertices of the cube.
So the two face sums together equal the sum of all eight labels:
(Such a labeling exists, for instance top face in cyclic order with directly below them, so the question is meaningful.)
The answer is .
Why this works
When a quantity is constant over several overlapping groups, look for a collection of those groups that covers every element exactly once; then the constant is forced without knowing the arrangement. Opposite faces of a cube are exactly such a partition. Counting the same total two ways is the heart of many "common sum" problems.
Alternative approach
Each vertex lies on faces, so adding all six face sums counts every label three times: , hence .
The trap
Trying to actually construct the labeling instead of noticing that opposite faces partition the vertices.
Common mistakes
- Trying to actually construct the labeling instead of noticing that opposite faces partition the vertices.
- Dividing by the number of faces () or by , forgetting that each vertex is counted on three faces.
Techniques
Exploit symmetry to reduce work or pair up objects