AMC 10 Step by Step

2004 AMC 10B Problem 6

P1-10~2 minPrint

Which of the following numbers is a perfect square?

Log in to save your progress.
Show solution without answering

Key insight

Write the bigger factorial as the smaller one times the extra numbers. For example 100! is 100 times 99!, so 99! times 100! is (99!) squared times 100, a square.

Solution

The numbers are huge, so do not try to compute them. Instead, use the fact that a bigger factorial contains the smaller one.

1. Start with a small example: 4!=4×3!4! = 4 \times 3!, because 4!=4×3×2×14! = 4 \times 3 \times 2 \times 1. In the same way, 100!=100×99!100! = 100 \times 99!.
2. So choice (C) is
99!⋅100!=99!⋅100⋅99!=(99!)2⋅100.99! \cdot 100! = 99! \cdot 100 \cdot 99! = (99!)^2 \cdot 100.
3. (99!)2(99!)^2 is a square, and 100=102100 = 10^2 is a square. A square times a square is a square: this is (99!⋅10)2(99! \cdot 10)^2. So (C) works.
4. Check that the others fail the same way, by pulling out a square and looking at what is left:
- (A) 98!⋅99!=(98!)2⋅9998! \cdot 99! = (98!)^2 \cdot 99. Leftover 99=9⋅1199 = 9 \cdot 11 has a single 1111, so not a square.
- (B) 98!⋅100!=(98!)2⋅99⋅10098! \cdot 100! = (98!)^2 \cdot 99 \cdot 100. Leftover 9900=100⋅9⋅119900 = 100 \cdot 9 \cdot 11, again a single 1111.
- (D) 99!⋅101!=(99!)2⋅100⋅10199! \cdot 101! = (99!)^2 \cdot 100 \cdot 101. Leftover has a single 101101, which is prime.
- (E) 100!⋅101!=(100!)2⋅101100! \cdot 101! = (100!)^2 \cdot 101. Leftover 101101 is prime, not a square.

The answer is (C) 99!⋅100!\boxed{\textbf{(C)}\ 99! \cdot 100!}.

Why this works

Factorials that are close together share almost all their factors. Rewrite the bigger one as the smaller one times a few extra numbers, pull out the square, and only the small leftover matters. A number is a perfect square exactly when every prime in it shows up an even number of times, so a lone 1111 or 101101 rules a choice out.

Concise solution

A shorter write-up, the way contest solutions are usually written. It may take a different route from the solution above.

Peel the larger factorial down to the smaller one. For any nn,
n!⋅(n+1)!=n!⋅(n+1)⋅n!=(n!)2⋅(n+1).n! \cdot (n+1)! = n! \cdot (n+1) \cdot n! = (n!)^2 \cdot (n+1).
Since (n!)2(n!)^2 is already a square, the product is a square exactly when the leftover factor n+1n + 1 is a square.

  • (A): (98!)2⋅99(98!)^2 \cdot 99; 9999 is not a square.
  • (C): (99!)2⋅100=(10⋅99!)2(99!)^2 \cdot 100 = (10 \cdot 99!)^2; a square.
  • (E): (100!)2⋅101(100!)^2 \cdot 101; 101101 is not a square.

For the choices two apart: (B) =98!⋅100!=(98!)2⋅99⋅100= 98! \cdot 100! = (98!)^2 \cdot 99 \cdot 100, and 99009900 is not a square because the factor 99=9⋅1199 = 9 \cdot 11 contributes an unpaired 1111. (D) =(99!)2⋅100⋅101= (99!)^2 \cdot 100 \cdot 101, and 101101 is prime, so it is not a square either.

The answer is (C) 99!⋅100!\boxed{\textbf{(C)}\ 99! \cdot 100!}.

Review in the AoPS books

Similar problems

Problem © Mathematical Association of America (MAA), American Mathematics Competitions. Reproduced for non-commercial educational use. Solution and commentary are original to this site.