Patty has coins consisting of nickels and dimes. If her nickels were dimes and her dimes were nickels, she would have cents more. How much are her coins worth?
- A)$1.15
- B)$1.20
- C)$1.25
- D)$1.30
- E)$1.35
Answer
A
Key insight
Each nickel swapped gains 5 cents and each dime swapped loses 5. A 70-cent gain means 14 more nickels than dimes: 17 and 3.
Solution
- Look at what the swap does to one coin at a time. A nickel turned into a dime gains cents. A dime turned into a nickel loses cents.
- So each nickel and dime cancel out in pairs. The overall gain of cents comes from the extra nickels: . She has more nickels than dimes.
- She has coins in all. Two numbers that add to and differ by : the bigger is and the smaller is . So nickels and dimes.
- Check the story: now she has cents. After swapping she would have cents. The difference is cents. It works.
- Her coins are worth cents.
The answer is .
Why this works
Instead of working out both totals, track the change the swap causes. Each coin changes by exactly cents, so the change only depends on how many more nickels than dimes there are. A sum ( coins) plus a difference ( more nickels) tells you both numbers.
Alternative approach
Each coin is worth cents in one version and cents in the other, so the two totals add up to cents. The swapped total is more than the real one. Two numbers that add to and differ by : the smaller is . So she has , and you never need to count the coins.
The trap
Getting the direction backwards and thinking she has more dimes (17 dimes, 3 nickels), which gives $1.85, not one of the choices.
Concise solution
Let be the number of nickels and the number of dimes, so .
Consider what the swap does coin by coin: each nickel becoming a dime adds cents, and each dime becoming a nickel removes cents. The net change is cents, and we are told it equals :
Adding this to gives , so and .
Her coins are worth cents.
The answer is .
Review in the AoPS books
- Introduction to Algebra, Chapter 3: One-Variable Linear Equations (§3.3, §3.4)
- Introduction to Algebra, Chapter 7: Proportion (§7.4)
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed