A base-10 three digit number is selected at random. Which of the following is closest to the probability that the base-9 representation and the base-11 representation of are both three-digit numerals?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
E
Key insight
Three digits in base b means b^2 <= n < b^3, so n must lie in [121, 728]; that is 608 of the 900 three-digit numbers, about 0.68.
Solution
A positive integer has exactly three digits in base when .
- Base : .
- Base : .
- Base (the sample space): , which is numbers.
All three conditions hold exactly when , an interval of integers.
The probability is , closest to .
The answer is .
Why this works
Digit counts are interval conditions: digits in base is the range . Intersecting the three intervals reduces the problem to counting integers in . The word "closest" signals an estimate is enough: is a bit over two thirds.
The trap
Treating 729 = 9^3 as a three-digit base-9 number (it is 1000 in base 9), or taking 100 rather than 11^2 = 121 as the smallest three-digit base-11 number.
Common mistakes
- Treating 729 = 9^3 as a three-digit base-9 number (it is 1000 in base 9), or taking 100 rather than 11^2 = 121 as the smallest three-digit base-11 number.
- Rounding down to or dividing by instead of .
Techniques
Bound the quantity above/below or estimate to pin it down