The arithmetic mean of the nine numbers in the set is a -digit number , all of whose digits are distinct. The number doesn't contain the digit
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
A
Key insight
Each number is 9 times a repunit, so the mean is 1 + 11 + 111 + ... + 111111111 = 123456789, which contains every digit except 0.
Solution
A string of nines equals times a string of ones. So dividing each member of the set by before adding, the mean is
Add by columns. The units column contains a from every one of the nine terms, so it sums to . The tens column gets a from the eight terms with at least two digits, giving ; the hundreds column gives ; and so on down to the leftmost column, which gets a single . Every column total is at most , so there are no carries, and reading the columns from left to right gives
The digits of are through ; the missing digit is .
The answer is .
Why this works
Dividing by before summing converts an ugly addition into a clean one. Repunits add column by column with no carries as long as at most nine of them overlap, so the sum spells out directly. Recognizing (or ) is the standard first move with all-nines numbers.
Alternative approach
Write each term as . The sum is , and dividing by by long division gives .
The trap
Trying to add the nine numbers first and then divide by 9, which invites carrying errors; dividing each term by 9 first makes the column sums 1 through 9.
Common mistakes
- Trying to add the nine numbers first and then divide by 9, which invites carrying errors; dividing each term by 9 first makes the column sums 1 through 9.
- Reading the column totals in the wrong order and writing ; the digit set is the same, so the answer survives, but the reasoning is off.
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed · Compute small cases, spot the pattern, generalize