Mr. Earl E. Bird gets up every day at 8:00 AM to go to work. If he drives at an average speed of 40 miles per hour, he will be late by 3 minutes. If he drives at an average speed of 60 miles per hour, he will be early by 3 minutes. How many miles per hour does Mr. Bird need to drive to get to work exactly on time?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
B
Key insight
The two trips differ by 6 minutes, so d/40 - d/60 = 1/10 hour gives d = 12 miles and the on-time trip takes 15 minutes.
Solution
Let the distance to work be miles. At mph the trip takes hours; at mph it takes hours. The first is minutes late and the second minutes early, so they differ by minutes hour:
The on-time duration is the mph time minus minutes: hours minutes, less minutes, is minutes hour. The required speed is
The answer is .
Why this works
Two trips over the same distance at known speeds, with a known time difference, always determine the distance through . Once and the target time are known, the needed speed is just distance over time. Keep units consistent by converting minutes to hours at the start.
Alternative approach
Because the late and early margins are equal, the on-time speed is the harmonic mean of and : . This works since the required time is the average of the two trip times, and time is distance over speed.
The trap
Averaging 40 and 60 to get 50, which ignores that the slower trip takes longer and so is weighted more heavily.
Common mistakes
- Averaging 40 and 60 to get 50, which ignores that the slower trip takes longer and so is weighted more heavily.
- Using minutes instead of for the difference between the trips, or leaving the minutes as hours in the equation.
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed