What is the maximum number of possible points of intersection of a circle and a triangle?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
E
Key insight
Each side of the triangle can cross the circle at most twice, so three sides give at most 6 points, and a slightly enlarged incircle reaches 6.
Solution
This asks for the greatest possible number, so there are two halves: show that more than is impossible, then show can happen.
Part 1: never more than .
- Draw a straight line and a circle. The line can miss the circle ( points), just touch it ( point), or cut through it ( points). It can never meet the circle times, because after going in and coming out, a straight line cannot turn back.
- Each side of a triangle is a piece of a straight line, so each side meets the circle at most times.
- There are sides, so the total is at most .
Part 2: is possible.
- Draw a triangle and a circle inside it that touches all three sides. That gives points.
- Now make the circle a little bigger, keeping the same center. Each side now cuts across the circle instead of just touching it, so each side crosses it twice, near where it used to touch.
- That gives points.
The answer is .
Why this works
For "maximum number of crossings" questions, count piece by piece: each side can add at most points, which gives a ceiling. Then draw a picture that reaches the ceiling. You need both halves: the picture alone does not prove you cannot do better, and the ceiling alone does not prove it can be reached.
The trap
Picturing a circle that just touches each side once (three points) and answering 3.
Concise solution
A straight line can cross a circle in at most two points, and each side of a triangle is part of a line. With three sides, the total number of intersection points cannot exceed .
To see that is actually possible, start with a triangle whose incircle touches all three sides, then enlarge the circle very slightly (keeping its center). Each former tangency point splits into two crossing points, one on each side of it, and all six lie on the sides of the triangle.
The answer is .
Review in the AoPS books
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 11: Circles
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 10: Geometric Inequalities
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 12: Circles and Angles
- Introduction to Geometry, Chapter 13: Power of a Point
Techniques
Bound the quantity above/below or estimate to pin it down