At Olympic High School, of the freshmen and of the sophomores took the AMC-10. Given that the number of freshmen and sophomore contestants was the same, which of the following must be true?
- A)
- B)
- C)
- D)
- E)
Answer
D
Key insight
Equal contestant counts give (2/5)f = (4/5)s, so f = 2s: the class with the smaller participation fraction must be twice as big.
Solution
Let be the number of freshmen and the number of sophomores. The contestant counts are and , and these are equal:
So there are twice as many freshmen as sophomores. Sanity check with numbers: freshmen send contestants, and sophomores also send .
The answer is
Why this works
If a smaller fraction of one group produces the same count as a larger fraction of another, the first group must be larger, in inverse proportion to the fractions. Writing the equation removes any doubt about direction; then read aloud as "freshmen are double the sophomores."
Alternative approach
Pick a convenient contestant count, say from each class. Freshmen: gives . Sophomores: gives . Twice as many freshmen.
The trap
Reversing the ratio and answering twice as many sophomores (B), because 4/5 is twice 2/5.
Common mistakes
- Reversing the ratio and answering twice as many sophomores (B), because 4/5 is twice 2/5.
- Reading "the number of contestants was the same" as "the classes are the same size" and choosing (C).
Techniques
Set up the equation/formula and compute; no special trick needed